Skip to main content

Book Review: Why We Broke Up by Daniel Handler

Why We Broke UpTitle: Why We Broke Up
Author: Daniel Handler
Series: Standalone
Pages: 354
Publisher: Electric Monkey
Date of Publication: 6th August 2012
Source: Publisher
Synopsis from Goodreads: I'm telling you why we broke up, Ed. I'm writing it in this letter, the whole truth of why it happened.

Min Green and Ed Slaterton are breaking up, so Min is writing Ed a letter and giving him a box. Inside the box is why they broke up. Two bottle caps, a movie ticket, a folded note, a box of matches, a protractor, books, a toy truck, a pair of ugly earrings, a comb from a motel room, and every other item collected over the course of a giddy, intimate, heartbreaking relationship. Item after item is illustrated and accounted for, and then the box, like a girlfriend, will be dumped.

My Thoughts:
There's a whole lot of hype surrounding this book. Whoever I talk to, it seems that Why We Broke Up is one of the best books that's been read recently. Everybody's raving, or recommending it, and I can kind of see why. I can imagine that for some people this book would be the best, but for me, not so much. It was not amazing, not bad, just a good, enjoyable, but probably forgettable read.

Maybe it's because I've never been through a break-up, (you need to have had a relationship for one of those... ;P ) but while I understood the story and it was easy for me to see it playing out in my head, I couldn't relate to the characters or the story they told. It felt more like a movie than a book - because when I watch movies I do it to relax - I watch them and then forget them. Maybe this is why I don't cry at sad movies - I just don't invest in the characters nearly as much as when I read. So that's why it felt like a movie - I found it difficult to really care about Min and Ed, and while I liked them and was interested in their story while reading it, they don't strike me as a couple who will stick in my mind for very long after I've finished this review and don't need to think about them again.

The book is told in the form of a super long letter that Min is giving to Ed, along with a box of objects that are somehow significant to their relationship: everyday, unimportant objects like a comb or a protractor, that someone outside of the story would not think twice about. I liked the way that every object had a story, and all these stories made up one big recount of the relationship between Min and Ed. It was great that we got all this detail and it was awesome to take every little step of their relationship with them. This idea was what interested me and I'm pleased to report that it did not disappoint.

The main reason I didn't enjoy this as much as I wanted to was the characters. They let the book down for me, as they just seemed particularly unremarkable. They were normal and kind of boring teenagers whom I didn't much care for. I found Min's writing style to be very awkward and it being written in second person (because it's a letter) sounded weird in my head. It's why I couldn't read Stolen by Lucy Christopher - I just can't get on with it, and I have no idea why. To me, it just sounds wrong... And Ed was cute but he always seemed kind of jerkish, right from the beginning. He kept going on about how Min was so different to every other girl he'd ever been with, and that would just annoy the crap out of me, so I didn't like him much. And at the end - what was he doing?! Nope, definitely didn't like him!

The best thing about this book though, were the amazing drawings that went with every chapter. There was a gorgeous image of whatever Min is talking about every few pages, and they are so well drawn and they go hand in hand with the story perfectly. Without them, this book would definitely not be the same. I also really liked all the old film references at the beginning. It would have been more awesome if the films mentioned were real films I could watch, but I thought it was cool that Min had something that she loved so much that she could relate it to everything in her life. She's such a film-nerd and it's awesome ;D

Overall, I enjoyed reading Why We Broke Up but I didn't think it was as amazing as everyone said it was. That's not to say I didn't like it - I did - just not as much as I was hoping to. I'd still recommend it, especially if you're a fan of YA contemporary, or if you've read the synopsis and you think it sounds good. Or, you could just buy it for the pictures, because they are freaking awesome.


  1. Come back to this after a break up, I think you'll have a different opinion then ;P

  2. Ooh, great review! I'm reading this at the moment and loving it so far. :)

  3. What a shame you didn't love it as much as you expected! I did though :)


Post a Comment

Thanks for commenting! :D I love comments, so comment away! :D

*I am no longer accepting blog awards :( I do not have time to go through all the things that come with it, and though I'm honoured you thought of me, I'm sure you can find someone who will love it, and be able to carry out the rules :)

Popular posts from this blog

This Mortal Coil by Emily Suvada: Review and Giveaway!

Hello! Today I have a review and giveaway for you guys! I was lucky enough to meet Emily Suvada this week, and so I've got a signed copy of This Mortal Coil to give away today!

Here's my review of this great book to whet your appetite!
Title: This Mortal Coil Author: Emily Suvada
Series:  This Mortal Coil, #1
Pages:  464
Publisher: Penguin Children's Books
Date of Publication: 2nd November 2017
Source: Waterstones
Synopsis from Goodreads:When a lone soldier, Cole, arrives with news of Lachlan Agatta's death, all hope seems lost for Catarina. Her father was the world's leading geneticist, and humanity's best hope of beating a devastating virus. Then, hidden beneath Cole's genehacked enhancements she finds a message of hope: Lachlan created a vaccine.

Only she can find and decrypt it, if she can unravel the clues he left for her. The closer she gets, the more she finds herself at risk from Cartaxus, a shadowy organization with a stranglehold on the world's genetic…

#readFreshers: BACK TO CAMPUS

Hey guys! Welcome to my stop on the Freshers blog tour. This book is hilarious and so much fun and I'm so excited to have Tom and Lucy on the blog today!

Here's Tom and Lucy's offering for today!
As soon as we started writing FRESHERS, we knew we wanted to go back to York university.  We spent three years there between 2001-2004 (Lucy) and 2002-2005 (Tom), and we knew that if we wanted to write a realistic campus novel, we had to go back to the campus we'd once called home. So, back in February 2016, we did. Here's a photo of Lucy reminiscing outside the big central hall building (which features quite a bit in FRESHERS). 

While we were on campus, we managed to sneak into our old corridors and have a look around, and it was comforting (and horrifying) to find out that students today are still as gross as we were back in 2001/2002. The corridors were sticky and smelly, and the kitchens were basically pasta-sauce-spattered bomb sites. We also spoke to as many genuine …

Book Review: Juniper Lemon's Happiness Index by Julie Israel

Title: Juniper Lemon's Happiness Index Author: Julie Israel
Series:  n/a
Pages:  308
Publisher: Penguin
Date of Publication: 1st June 2017
Source: For review from publisher*
Synopsis from Goodreads:It's hard to keep close a person everyone keeps telling you is gone.

It's been sixty-five painful days since the death of Juniper's big sister, Camilla. On her first day back at school, bracing herself for the stares and whispers, Juniper borrows Camie's handbag for luck - and discovers an unsent break-up letter inside. It's mysteriously addressed to 'You' and dated July 4th - the day of Camie's accident. Desperate to learn the identity of Camie's secret love, Juniper starts to investigate.

But then she loses something herself. A card from her daily ritual, The Happiness Index: little notecards on which she rates the day. The Index has been holding Juniper together since Camie's death - but without this card, there's a hole. And this particular card …